I can afford one game, and one game only.

[Ssenkahdavic]

STEKSTAV said:

 

1.Red Dead Redemption - Length, multiplayer, Wild Wild West(!)
2.Alan Wake - Story, Epicness, Graphics, Horror
3.Heavy Rain - Story, Innovative, Hype, Graphics, My girl wants it.
4.BFBC2 - FPS, Multiplayer, Funfactor
5.God of War - Epicness, Story, Graphics, Hype, Mayhem
6.Batman AA - GOTY, Unique, Batman, Replay value

 

   

Is my answer for ya.  For length of play, multiplayer and the fact that you already have it at number 1.