XII is a 10. I can never decide if I like it or IX more. One of the best, most fully-realized worlds in a console RPG, and the best script/voicework of any video game. The story falls apart towards the end and combat isn't that interesting, but those are small qualms in comparison to the game's achievements. Also, Balthier is the best character in a Final Fantasy.
XIII is a 5. Spectacular battle system only partially makes up for the atrocious story, script, voicework, pacing, and Vanille. And the linearity, lack of towns, lack of meaningful NPC interactions, lack of a real villain. Also, Leona Lewis. Shoddy soundtrack altogether.







