You claim Alan Wake has the "best lighting ever" have you played Uncharted 2?
*Spoilers*
Uncharted 2 can do torches and darkness too, I dare you to find the flat textures and blocky objects that are seen all over Alan Wake too, in all the screenshots theres loads of square objects and not many extra props in scenes unless it's baked into textures.
For a more realistic styled environment how about Heavy Rain?
*Spoilers*
This isn't a PS3 vs 360 thing, I'd compare it to other 360 games, but I know these look better so they were easiest to find, most MW2 footage is probably PC. These are gameplay videos too, not cream of the crop screenshots.
Alan Wake may look great, I don't deny that, but it just REALLY isn't THAT amazing like people are making out, honestly, it's driving me nuts, lol.
-Insert PSN Portable ID here-
-Insert XBL Portable ID here-
-Insert Witty Quote/Comment here-
