By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
ElGranCabeza on 09 April 2010
Edit Thread
Luney Tune said:
ElGranCabeza said:

Actually no, most of what you wrote is opinion, you do have a couple of facts there. The only facts you have there is that VF5 is better than the PS3 online - considering the PS3 version is not even online that's a given, that DOA4 is an exclusive game, albeit a very bad one IMHO. While most multiplat are indeed better on 360, that's not actually the case with the fighting games as they're pretty much equal across all platforms. Your assumption that any JRPG fan that loves DS = PS3 fanboy is ludcirous at best, especially considering DS is one of the highest praised games this generation, getting numerous awards, winning RPG of the year from certain places last year and even getting Gamespot 2009 overall Game of the Year. Your description of bosses is also very poor, no offense, and I don't blame you for not remembering, since you hated the game.


Samurai Shodown Sen is a 360 exclusive: FACT.

Multiplatform fighting games are for the most part a little better on the 360. FACT. According to Eurogamer/Digital Foundry Street Fighter IV is superior on the 360, Soul Calibur IV is marginally better, while Tekken 6 is considered equal on both systems. According to Lens of Truth, Street Fighter IV and Tekken 6 are both slightly better on the 360 (although 360 Tekken 6 won because of faster load times from disc, which is a stupid argument as both games offer a HD install option). BlazBlue is considered equal on both systems. I wasn't able to find a single fighting game that was considered superior on the PS3 on either site.

   http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/face-off-street-fighter-iv-article

   http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/xbox-360-vs-ps3-face-off-round-14-article?page=2

   http://www.lensoftruth.com/?p=4042

   http://www.lensoftruth.com/?p=15929

The 360 hardware scaler can considerably reduce input lag in fighting games. FACT.

I wasn't describing the bosses in Demon's Souls, I was describing how I killed them with little effort. And you can indeed kill all the smaller stingrays (or whatever the hell they're called) safely from within (not behind) the house if you're patient. It's actually a great farming spot for souls if I remember correctly.

And I *never* claimed that "JRPG fan that loves DS = PS3 fanboy". You're twisting my words. And the fact that Demon's Souls is a widely praised game doesn't mean unbiased JRPG lovers in general will like it.

Yeah I missed that Samurai Shodown Sen, it's not hard to miss a game with a 49 metacritic though.....

Not a fact:

Street Fighter IV metacritic - PS3=94 360=93

Tekken 6 metacritic - PS3=79 360=80

Soul Calibur IV metacritic - PS3=85 360=85

BlazBlue metacritic - PS3=88 360=87


Those are the significant fighting games this generation unless I missed any, about the same score!

I'm not a technical guy but the "lag", or lack thereof, I "get" from my 360 is the same as I "get" from my PS3. You might be right, you might be wrong though, I don't know, but if it makes you sleep better at night I'll give you that and say I missed that "fact" too.

You must be the most patient man in the world then, but either way I can make any game sound boring and horrible as well. And I didn't twist your words, that's what you said! Unbiased JRPG fans might love Demon's Souls as well, so you're just saying that any JRPG fan that liked Demon's Souls is automatically biased.


Anyways I'm completely done with this topic, I'm not one to keep debating stuff on the internet. I thought you'd agree to disagree, I guess not, either way, reply and feel happy that you "won" our "argument".