Reasonable on 07 April 2010
He's so wrong with so much evidence stacked against him, going waaayyyy back, that it's not even funny.
An exclusive title can easily redefine a genre - and in fact many exclusives have.
As for Uncharted 2... I'd say it just qualifies by the skin of its teeth. It was for the most part refinement vs redefining, but as a complete package I think it did just about scrape over the line as it pushed so many elements to another level.
IMHO of course.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
