Heavy Rain is, in many ways, not well written (Spoilers)

[Stefan.De.Machtige]

 CGI-Quality said:

vegafoo said:
But people do it all the time with movies. You could take a movie like Silence of the Lambs or Seven or Fight Club and pick it apart and point out all of the ridiculousness just like this guy is doing with Heavy Rain.

But instead, people suspend their disbelief and ignore the little inconsistencies and minor plot holes in order to enjoy otherwise gripping and entertaining stories.

Heavy Rain gets scrutinized way too much. But I guess that's just a side effect of being a very vocal pioneer in a still relatively young medium.

With that, I don't even need to add input.

It may be a bit.

But to be fair, most - if not all - games are scrutinized too much on this site.