Mafia Round 15B - Game Thread

[trangentspree]

nordlead said:

trangentspree said:

Some counterpoints:

• Apparently it's not a big deal and maybe not my own fault, yet it's still worth dredging up again? This point in particular makes me think you're just throwing all the muck possible in hopes that something will stick.

You accuse me of 'acting very similar to the game' but

• I was the SK then and not mafia (different agenda)
• This is only my second game, you don't have a basis to judge how my play changes according to alignment
• And best of all - irony: you are playing a lot like your last game in that you talked a bit at the start and then completely disappeared - and you turned out to be mafia
• Following on from this, you only re-emerged now since suspicion on j0 lifted and he asked for you to be modkilled/lynched for lurking - which is either a very lucky coincidence for you or you have been watching this game without playing this whole time (hoping somebody else would get the chop?)

 

I'm not specifically defending Falcon, but I will say that most games he plays in he typically only posts once per 24hours (or in other words, at a very slow rate). This also leads to people asking for the town to lynch him or being modkilled.

I wouldn't make your decision on if he is scum or not based on lurking. However, if the game does end up going nowhere we typically use him as the sacrificial lynch to appease the town

The problem with the majority (while really being a plurality) thing, is that you tried to use it as a defense for why you aren't human cause you could have stopped the lynch. However, you wouldn't have stopped the lynch. This is why it keeps getting brought up. While I don't care since I think it is a simple misunderstanding of how the game would be played, I can see why people are interested in it.

You're not defending Falcon, and then you go on to defend Falcon.

And I remember him from the last game. He posted a lot during the first two days and then completely disappeared. I don't know about his history prior to this, but he shouldn't be judging me from the same standpoint that makes himself sound guilty.

You're not interested in the majority thing and think it is a misunderstanding and yet you don't mind dredging it up again

So far only you, Falcon and Final-Fan have taken exception to this - and Final-Fan never used it to suggest I was antitown.