The ultimate thread killing point in this whole 'massive userbase should equal massive hit' argument is the PS2. It's the best selling console of all time, it's got one of the best gaming libraries of all time and it's sold more software than any other console. But it doesn't have any games with twenty million sales, and only five with more than ten million.
Meanwhile, five different Nintendo consoles have games with twenty million sales or more, four of them have several games with those kind of sales, with only the SNES having just the one game at that level, and yet none of those consoles beats the PS2 in userbase size. In fact the PS2 dwarfs several of those consoles.
What's that I hear you say now? The higher the userbase the more diversified the sales are? Doesn't that support the argument of the OP?
VGChartz
