The people have spoken and it looks like it's God of War 2.
To break things up I'll probably finish Gears of War 2 in there at some point just because I really need to and if I encounter another puzzle as frustratingly awful as the God-damned spike puzzle in God of War I'll just rage quit and move onto Batman.
-edit-
Fuck...thinking about that spike puzzle has me angry again. I was actually talking to another buddy who is playing through God of War for the first time and he did rage quit there.
I actually brought up a YouTube video of someone playing it after I failed at it for an hour and the time limit on the puzzle is variable! Why the fuck would anyone do that! How stupid can you be!? Ugh, that was just so shitty and they even knew it because they gave you a silver trophy for suffering though it. I would rather skip adding the trophy and make it a constant time and give me another second.
Anyways, point for editing!
@Darth (from another thread that got locked)
There's a difference in asking what game I should play next and if I should leave the site forever because I can't ignore fanboys. 
