By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
mattbfg said:
would a platinum star rating system be better off if you had maybe set criteria for a game to earn the stars?
e.g if a game took under 10 hours it doesnt get a star, over 10 hours it gets a star but maybe two stars if over 50 hour.
multiple play throughs maybe gets a star on reptitiveness and a star for diffcultness

its a weak template of an idea and just throwing an alternative out there and well aware that there is flaws with it :)

Thanks for the suggestion. So, you're saying that we could award stars to a game based on platinum requirements like total play time, if multiple play throughs are required, difficulty, etc?

Example: Uncharted

Total Play time >10 hour = 1 star
+
Multiple Play throughs = 1 star
+
Is it difficult? No = 0 stars
=
2 stars Overall

Is that how it would work? If not, please elaborate with some examples. I see some problems, but interesting idea.