Honestly, I was burnt out after every God of War game, fun as they feel at first. I can't imagine jumping right from one into the next, though that's just me.
I also really question anyone wanting to give Deadly Premonition "a chance" based on the nice Destructoid review.
Games that are so bad they're good are a nice idea, but the fact is, even huge games like Gears of War 2 and God of War are already B Movies as far as the writing is concerned -- the concept of "so bad it's good" pretty much applies to every video game story ever penned.
Except for the ones which are so bad they're bad, I guess -- which kinda comes down to personal taste, and whether or not your roommate or girlfriend are there to snicker in the background at the cheesy dialog and make you feel self-conscious during cutscenes. (Which is what we like to call the "immersion" factor) I'm not sure why a game with fucked up play mechanics gets extra props, except of course that referencing David Lynch at least proves the people writing your scenarios are over 21.
I would suggest Gears of War 2, but I seem to remember you being friend-phobic when it comes to couch-based gameplay, and that's the only way I've ever played that game. Great coop campaign, especially if you've got a friend who likes to make awkward bromance jokes a la Mystery Science Theater 3000.
I still have to play through Bioshock 1... Damn that game has good music.
Anyway, sorry if I over analyzed your game list :(
