@Jboy
We'll I was just talking about my experience and reasoning why it was a 2 and not a 3 for me. God of War III was not a 3 star based on the difficulty and time that I had and put into it. But had I not started on Normal first I definitely would have died a lot more on Titan mode and I may have walked away thinking it was a 3 in this case.
In Arcturus example he shows God of War I is a 5 out of 10. Well this would be a 2.5 on a scale of 1-5. It's unfortunate that we don't have the extra .5 to work with because God of War gets rounded down to a 2 in this case. Even God of War III at a 5.8 gets rounded down to a 2. Although I would take your side here and argue that a 5.8 should be rounded up to a 6 and therefore a 3. Anything above 5.5 should.
