Great:
Wii
360
GameCube
Ok:
N64... Kinda hated the 3rd handle.. it was kinda pointless. If the anolog was where the dpad was it would of been perfect.
Horrible:
PSX,PS2,PS3.. I hate they named the buttons. I couldn't get it when I was a kid and I still can't get it now. The feel of it is alright when controlling.
Xbox.. size does matter in this case.