Valkyria Chronicles best HD JRPG this gen ?

[jarrod]

ps3_jrpg_gamer said:

jarrod said:
Well, it a literal sense, FFXIII is with a metascore of 83 (both PS3 & 360 btw). If we drop the "RPG" qualifier and include subgenres, then Demon's Souls is with a metascore of 89. If we drop the "J" qualifier and include RPGs developed in all regions, then Mass Effect 2 is with a metascore of 96.

i have wrote here earlier here why i didn 't put Demon 's Soul and if i had did it this Thread would have  top 1,000 replies with even if it is and as it seems some make the same thing with valkyria which i didn 't expected

Have you played Valkyria?  Is it really a surprise people said it's not a JRPG?