I'm back trangentspree. Frankly I'm a bit disapointed by supermario's reasoning because if it's true then that's very sloppy on his part not to read both his PM and the OP before posting in the thread.
About the lynching on the first day thing, I'm on the fence about it. I'm guessing there's only one night kill per night since we're only nine players. If we're facing three humans a first day lynch would put us a the brink of defeat very quickly if we make the wrong choice but on the other hand catching a human on the first day would make things much better for the town.
In the end, I'm still weighing if supermario's behavior is scummy enough to warrant taking that risk.
Signature goes here!