what is your favorite western rpg of all time ?

[lestatdark]

gurglesletch said:

lestatdark said:

gurglesletch said:

lestatdark said:

gurglesletch said:

lestatdark said:

gurglesletch said:

dobby985 said:

gurglesletch said:

dobby985 said:

gurglesletch said:
1.Oblivion
2.Fallout 3
3.Far Cry 2

Far Cry 2 is not a roleplaying game.

Yes it is.

It's a first-person shooter made by Crytek. It contains no RPG elements whatsoever.

It is an RPG. FAR CRY 2 was made and published by Ubisoft so get your facts straight before you try slamming a game i like. Also Crytek uses EA as their publisher.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far_Cry_2

http://farcry.us.ubi.com/index.php?page=story

"Far Cry® 2, the next-generation first-person shooter from Ubisoft, will take you deep into the most beautiful but also most hostile environments in the world: Africa! More than just a visual and technological achievement, Far Cry® 2, the true sequel to the award-winning PC game, will provide you with an unprecedented gaming experience." 

So, you know better than the producers themselves? XD 

It says nowhere it was made by Crytek and you play as a mercenary so you are role playing.

I'm talking about the RPG claim. In any game ever made in which you play as someone, you're doing a role. That's far from it being an RPG. By your definition, every single game that involves a character is a RPG.  

So yeah...good luck with that 

I know that COD is an RPG but the story is to short to include it on this list. Besides Far Cry 2 has a weapon upgrade and degradation sytem. It also allows you to do missions for your buddies to upgrade your safehouses so it has a lot more RPG elements than COD. 

You seriously don't know what a RPG is. I'm through discussing it with you, cracking my head on walls isn't worth it XD 

Yes, i have won. Anyway, most games are RPG's so i really don't see what you were arguing with me about. 

Of course, of course, here's some fireworks for you xD