SmoothCriminal on 21 March 2010
2002- Morrowind
2003- Sands of Time (I believe it came out in '03, I could be wrong)
2004- Half-Life 2
2005- Resident Evil 4 (Once again not sure)
2006- Twilight Princess
2007- Mario Galaxy/Mass Effect
2008- No More Heroes
2009- Dragon Age: Origins
2010 (so far)- Mass Effect 2
As far as 2010 goes, Starcraft 2 and Zelda Wii have a chance, but as far as I'm concerned, Mass Effect 2 is GotY
