Hmm... I can try this...
FF1: 3.8/5. A large open world with plenty to explore. Your magic is customizable, and forced you to make decisions.
FF2: 3.5/5. It's more of the same, except that what you did you got good at, and what you didn't do, decayed. Keeping magic up was annoying, though...
FF3: 3.9/5. A changing party member, and the beginning of job classes really made you start holding on to things!
FF4: 4.5/5. HOW many overworlds were there to play with? And all the characters... really, it's excellent!
FF5: 4.8/5. Near perfection. We fixed the job class problems from 3, and kept it a nice and challenging game.
FF6: 4.7/5. Another excellent game, it would beat FF5 if it weren't so easy compared to it.
FF7: 2.2/5. What happened? Linear dungeons, painfully easy... all it has is graphics?
FF8: 0.4/5. Hello, bottom of barrel. Everything failed here, but at least we got Triple Triad out of the deal...
FF9: 2.9/5. Better, but still too easy and too linear. Minigames felt better tied-in, too.
FF10: 1.0/5. Hello, linearity! I can take a nap now?
FF10-2: 0.8/5. Ugh, more of the characters from 10 I didn't like, with fanservice ratched up that I don't care for.
FF11: 0.5/5. MMO + FF really don't mix...
FF12: 2.5/5. Good ideas, poor execution. And I don't like losing control of my party; at least I could switch back...
FF13: 0.7/5. The linearity of 10, with new graphics and less to find! AND I can't control others in my party!
And for shits and giggles...
FFT: 2.8/5. Decent game, but horribly unbalanced. Enemy skills are off, and how does my 100% chance to hit miss??
FFMQ: 3.1/5. It bills itself as an easy RPG, and it is. However, random values are a fail...
FFL: 3.3/5. I... don't like breaking weapons. And the curve between early floors and item costs is very high. But it's also very rewarding later in.
FFL2: 3.7/5. The curve is fixed, but other problems remain.
FFL3: 4.2/5. Hey... less breaking weapons, and now even robots? Sign me up!
FFCC: 3.8/5. It rocks for multiplayer, but timing's a bitch. It also encourages you to go through boards multiple times to get more items!
FFCB: 3.0/5. Umm... FF? Where are you? It's not a bad action/adventure game, but I don't get an FF vibe.
FF4AY: 4.6/5. I thought Square forgot how to make a game this good! It's more FF4, and I can choose who I use!
Yes, there are others too. But I think I've already gone into overkill...
-dunno001
-On a quest for the truly perfect game; I don't think it exists...







