Uncharted 2 May Be The Greatest Game in Existence

[PearlJam]

CGI-Quality said:

PearlJam said:
The only way I can see this being the best game ever, is if the PS3 is the first and only system you have ever owned or played in your life. Are the people that think this way new to gaming? I believe it is a great game with some of the best graphics, but that is about it.

I didn't like the first game too much. To me it was a very average game with nice visuals.

Rememer those words, because they are the theme in this thread. Uncharted 2 doesn't have to be YOUR "fave game of all time" for it to be somebody else's. Claiming that people may have only played a PS3 for that to be such is short-sighted. Many people enjoyed it THAT much. I don't see what's wrong with that.

There is nothing short sighted about it, it's far more short-sighted to declare ANY game the "Best Game Ever". I've been gaming since the NES days, and when I look back on it all this game doesn't even crack my top 10. Any body that lived through NES, SNES, N64 and PS1 will have a hard time pointing to any current  game and declaring it the best of all time.