GOW3 deserves a 10 because??? it's refreshing and bring a whole lot of new ideas to the table?
Same old with prettier splash of paint does not deserve 10, nor any game that is a direct sequel or even the last part in a trilogy that has nothing new to a button masher.
Gear3 should not, nor should MGS4 ( that's the 4 game for god sakes) how much of the same content are we paying for with a different story and some gameplay changes...
When the next systems come out we'll be seeing MGS5..6 7.. FFXX...-_-', god..have we reach the point of no return? I am feeling sad even to see SMG2... Even Nintendo got caught in the sequel limbo. Pikmin3...
Anyways the point is, as a reviewer you base your review on some basic facts and to deserve a 10 means it is perfect and you feel its fresh, it raised the bar, brought something new. a whole lot must be taken into consideration. Not some fanboy of the series and say. YES!!! you've been waiting for this for ever. Looks prettier, plays the same, Kratos looks badass in HD... I don't see how you review an updated version of a game and say this is a 10.
See if the new LOZ gets a 10 that is a series, with ever changing gameplay mechanics and art style etc, but most of these games are same old with fresh coat of paint. IDk if i'm making sense.








