Will Halo Reach outsell Halo 3.

[fastyxx]

ymeaga1n said:

fastyxx said:

ymeaga1n said:
Everyone please ignore the x360 fans which are saying it will outsell Halo 3. Because it will NOT.

Has there been a franchise even close to this level on Playstation or Xbox that HASN'T had a full sequel sell better than its predecessor?   I can only think of a couple examples, and it's more when they sequalized to death ala Tony Hawk or Guitar hero or something.

There's no indication anywhere that this wouldn't sell at least as well.

You said sequel 2 times...that's where you're wrong. This isn't a sequal, it's a prequel. Please go find me history were a prequel outsold the game it came after. Resident evil zero? MSG3? I'm pretty sure they didn't.

I think you're underestimating what master chief is to the halo franchise. Look at ODST. I expect reach to do much better then ODST, but not Halo 3 league.

ODST wasn't a true sequel, as has been discussed a billion times.  It was more an experiment and fans service.

And Reach is a sequel to the game, not the story.  

I love the Halo fiction - all the books, the Halopedia, the anime.  But virtually no one's buying the games for the story.  Halo is all about gameplay, and they build what story there is around it.  It doesn't matter when it's set or whether MC and Cortana is in it.  You're underestimating the relevance of the actual game here.  

If people bought games simply for the story, the best seller list would be very very different.  Gameplay, gameplay, gameplay.  I really loved the Super MArio Kart story.  It was enthralling.  And WiiFit.  The only games in the top 50 worldwide this week for example, that sell because of story in any argument are probably Mass Effect 2 and Heavy Rain?  Maybe an RPG?  Certainly not shooters.  

And by far the most popular element of a Halo game is multi-player, in which Master Chief has no part.  The only reason ODST sold less is that everyone already owned the multiplayer.  

 

We'll see who's right in September.  *shrug*  But I don't buy your argument in the least.    It just doesn't make sense when you actually look at the way games sell.