Lost tears of Kain said:
I have zero problems letting super mario galaxy win, i have problems with the top games for the other two systems are eliminated right off the bat by the wii fans. They will always put their games on top. I can see the hate on this site by the fact that halo 3 got knocked off right from the start. They eleminated the games they disliked not the games they saw as goty potential. Theres a difference. If this was a vote where everyone voted their favorite games i have no problem letting those two games win, cause its popular vote and goes to what you state. Theres a difference when anything they like is so much more danm deserving of goty over anything else on other systems. I do not like metroid but it doesnt stop me from voting that is goty potential, why i voted down orange box because i dont think a rehash of a bunch of different games and some added things is GOTY material.
In all this was a popular vote, proving that nintendo fans dominate and only consider their games goty potential and dont consider anybodys else worth a danm. |
I totally agree. I mean Halo 3 was the first game eliminated. Just flat out ridiculous. I mean, it broke the entertainment record for most sale dollars in one day! I'm not necessarily saying it should have been game of the year, but come on! SMG is a nice game. I played it for about a week. I was a little un-impressed with it, to be honest. That's why I sold it and my Wii (for the second time now) for about a $100 profit. For me Mass Effect doesn't appeal to me and Bioshock didn't impress me with the demo I played. I would have to go with Gears of War, but I could stand SMG or Halo 3 winning it (for real).