Mendicate Bias on 18 February 2010
Two goty editions, a ps2 game and a dlc with only 10 reviews. I think its pretty fair to say that your list is extremely biased.
While metacritic has its faults all games go through the same metric and it is the far more reputable site as it is actually used by both publishers an developers.
The definitive evidence that video games turn people into mass murderers
Essay Pro