What about the 50,000 who downloaded the game? I'm sure they knew very well what they were doing. Anyway, yes what he did was illegal, and what he must do is pay for it, but he is far from the only person at fault, and he isn't responsible for the choices of 50,000 people. Personally I think there is a line that needs to be drawn, and 1.6 million for uploading a video game is well past that line.