IGN: Best Games OVERALL! (And the winner is....)

[slowmo]

Boutros said:

freebs2 said:

Boutros said:

freebs2 said:

dobby985 said:

Snesboy said:
I stand by my previous point. Uncharted 2 is not deserving to be on that list.

Exactly, It's a combination of Gears of War with the easiest of Tomb Raider puzzles.

(Not my words but I agree with who originally said that)

Totally agree.

"It's a combination of Gears of War with the easiest of Tomb Raider puzzles."

 

And that makes it a bad game/not deserving to be on the list?

There is some difference beetween being considered a bad game and a top10 decade game.

There are a lot of orignial games that deserves to be on that list a lot more than an average action carbon-copy game. Even if it has good graphics, good but repetitive gameplay and all....

Uncharted is not an average action game and certainly not a carbon-copy game. You just don't know what you're talking about.

 

And that's the way the list is made. They took each GOTY and they made a list with them.

If they made it that way then it explains why it is so utterly awful, thats a terribly flawed method of selection when you consider it doesn't take into account some years have more great games than others.