IGN: Best Games OVERALL! (And the winner is....)

[EncodedNybble]

ssj12 said:

Gilgamesh said:

Horrible

No Metal Gear Solid games, no Final Fantasy (X) games (even Crisis Core deserves to be there), San Andreas was waaaaaay better then III.

I disagree with you. MGS has way to many flaws. Final Fantasy is a great RPG series, but I'd place The Witcher way before FF. And San Andreas didnt revolutionize the third-person action adventure genre like III, because well III was the first in the series to do it and did it well..

Put shouldn't the list be of "best" games not "most revolutionary/influential"?  In that case, wouldn't SA be on that list instead of III?