By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
makingmusic476 on 08 February 2010
Edit Thread
Slimebeast said:
CommonMan said:
Slimebeast said:
It's hard to pick between GTA4 and Resi 5 - which is more overrated, a 9.0 game that got 98% Meta or a 6.5 game that got 85% Meta?


Hey! That's my personal 2009 GOTY you're trashing there me boy! Them's fightin' words! *puts up his dukes*

Edit: RE5, that is.

Really? And here I thought you were a reasonable man lol. It's so flawed. Biggest disappointment of 2009 IMO. I could stretch to giving it a 7 though.

I would say it was overhyped moreso than its overrated.  Peopel expected the next RE4, and we got a weak action game.  It scored in the low 8s, about what it deserves.

OT:

I'd have to go with GTAIV.  They took out a lot of what made GTA fun for me, and I couldn't get into the game at all.  I also think MW2 is overrated, based on what I've heard about how it compare to the first, but I haven't played it enough (only 2-3 hours) to really comment.