The Rumor About Sonic Appearing in Super Mario Galaxy 2 is False!

[GameGuy100]

EL_PATRAS said:

mike_intellivision said:
Right now ... it is a rumor. No official word has either confirmed or denied this to the best of my knowledge (the OP does not count).

What I do not understand is why anyone would be against this. Because if it was done by Nintendo people, it would be done well.

As far as whether or not it is true, remember that most of the talk was that much of the game was being done with the parts that did not make SMG(1). That is probably the strongest argument against at this time.

Mike from Morgantown

This.

Also, I'm sorry to say that the OP's reasons don't make all that much sense.  Why are people arguing if sonic can or can't swim anyway, it's obvious he can (original sonic games) and even if he couldn't, would it really matter enough to not put him in the game. 

Like I said: He can't swim in the original games. All he can do is spend a certain amount of time underwater. If there are no platforms for him to jump on, he will drown.