Chairman-Mao on 07 February 2010
Definitely Fallout 3 if you haven't played it already. You could easily get both Resistance 1 and 2 for less then the price of a new game (and they're both great, although slightly outdated). Uncharted for sure! It's really cheap now and if you're in NA then you can get it and a controller for $55.
I know you said you're not sure about InFamous, but I think its only $40 now. Sony dropped the price recently.
