Killzone 2 or Halo 3?

[Squilliam]

gamings_best said:

Squilliam said:

Killzone 2 = Wolf 3D = A statement I made? I think not. I was responding to someone who thought I was talking about a date instead of a metacritic rating.

Theres nothing wrong with Resistance Fall of Man, I simply said they were about one and the same in terms of gameplay once you took out the inflation of Killzone 2's scores due to higher graphics. Both are to me 85-89% games.

so you think the game without it'd graphics would be considered a lower quality game?

do you think had halo come out after killzone, and had killzone 2 lv. of hype would still be considered of same quality as it is now?

 

Considering the number of debates on graphics vs gameplay I think it wouldn't change anything. However it would change the review scores which pick out graphics as a proportion of the overall score.

Halo 3 has 10M sales, 100+ hours average play time, so yes. Do the averages, more people have played and played for longer than any other shooter this generation. You can make people buy a game with hype sometimes, but you can't make them keep playing it if it wasn't any good.