NFL Prediction League

[Sqrl]

CrimsonRevolver said:

Sqrl said:

Why not actually quote my comment when responding to it?

"Now understand that Drew Brees is by no means an "elite QB" yet, that kind of status is built up over a career."

Oh, now I see.....

I think to quote something that long is fail. You know what you said. Or did you forget?

I guess I proved my point. /thread

Sentences are too long to quote?

Of course I know what I said, but the point is you can't have that sentence above your post because it highlights how flimsy your comment really is.

I'll go over it just so its clear to you:

• I say the careers aren't what matters to this game, that it's what they've done this season.
• I say Brees is not an elite QB because that status is built over a career.
• You point to my comment of Brees not being an elite QB of proving your point that Manning as an edge due to his career.

This is a pretty obvious failure of logic.  The argument you should be making, if you care to discuss the issue at all, is why the career matters more in a single game than their recent performances.

PS - Considering that I'm the OP of the thread and that I'm running this league...I say when its /thread.

edit: PPS - Oh and were you going to give any of those specific forecasts of how Manning would display his advantage in the game?