IGN: Best Games of 2008 (Wow)

[selnor]

epicurean said:

selnor said:

dtewi said:
*gibberish* WHAT?

Mirror's Edge: 7.4
MGS4: 10

Mirror's Edge > MGS4!?

How does that make ANY sense?

Obviously alot of people who voted at IGN for this list did not think MGS4 was anything like a 10.

Come on selnor, even the biggest 360 fanboy has to admit something is up...MGSIV didn't have a SINGLE review score under 80, and Mirror's Edge AVERAGED a 79.  (Prince of Persia, for the 360 - the box cover the showed - averaged a 81)

So you're saying all of the sudden MGS4 went from a consensus triple A game to the average of all the IGN staff being LESS than the lowest score it received from any publication?  Even you have to admit its a bit of a head scratcher....

IT's a like it or hate it game. These best of's by IGN are voted on by may. Not jus the one guy who did the review. So during the vote. Whoever voted on it the other games came up more often and higher up. Hell Gears 2 got a better score than alot of those, and thats not even there. It's just voted by more than 1 person.