IGN: Best Games of 2008 (Wow)

[epicurean]

selnor said:

dtewi said:
*gibberish* WHAT?

Mirror's Edge: 7.4
MGS4: 10

Mirror's Edge > MGS4!?

How does that make ANY sense?

Obviously alot of people who voted at IGN for this list did not think MGS4 was anything like a 10.

Come on selnor, even the biggest 360 fanboy has to admit something is up...MGSIV didn't have a SINGLE review score under 80, and Mirror's Edge AVERAGED a 79.  (Prince of Persia, for the 360 - the box cover the showed - averaged a 81)

So you're saying all of the sudden MGS4 went from a consensus triple A game to the average of all the IGN staff being LESS than the lowest score it received from any publication?  Even you have to admit its a bit of a head scratcher....