This thread just shows people are more keen to agree with someone then disagree. If you were unsure this game would be good, then see all these reviews, you can say you were right all along.
There are going to be people who don't like this game, thats fine. But don't hate on it based on Gamespot or IGN. Do some research, try it out, whatever. If you've read about it and it doesnt appeal , thats fine. Don't get it. But dont think Gamespot is automatically correct about everything.
I've really enjoyed this game so far. Better then any RPG i played in 2009 besides the Star Ocean 2 remake. I know this game won't top Final Fantasy, or even Star Ocean 4, but i am glad i got it.
Currently own: PC (duh), SNES, Game Boy, Game Boy Color, Game Boy Advance, PS1, PS2, PS3, PSP.