Uncharted 2 was a good game, but it wasn't a complete package. I agree with many of the points raised within the article. The single player experience doesn't justify a 100% score, not sure about multiplayer though. I would personally give the game about an 85% rating.
My guess is the critics were smoking the leftover crack they got with their GTA IV review copies.
Do you know what its like to live on the far side of Uranus?