Nobuo Uematsu vs. Yasunori Mitsuda

[selnor]

Khuutra said:

selnor said:

It's not a list war. It's the facts. If you want to say who is better, you need to know what they have worked on. Especially what they have worked on completely on their own. Mitsuda has alot fewer games which is solely him. Uematsu has alot with no help. And just look at the games both have worked on. I'll let you find out which games won music awards in Japan. Let me tell you it's more than 70-30 in Uematsus favour. It's so obvious why Uematsu is not getting votes on this site.

No, it is a list war. That's exactly what it is. Awards do not mean shit in the context of these discussions!

Please tell me you aren't trying to turn this discussion into some petty 360 vs PS3 thing

Come on man. your joking right?

I know nothing about who played for LA Lakers yet I'll just say Kobe was the best LA ever had. Because thats all I know. See?

You HAVE to know credentials when picking a winner. Or what the hell is the point. No I dont mean 360 vs PS3 ( Uematsu is working on FF14 alone ) I mean the super sad people who want FF13 to be so great they will say Mitsuda no matter what. Even though he has had alot of composers help in all but 6 or 7 of his games. 2 of those games from Uematsu. Look at it this way Uematsu has been Freelance since 2004. Yet SquareEnix still contract him work alone, they trust an entire game to him. That is an exceptional composer. Mitsuda doesnt have half the resume Uematsu has. And none of his best stuff is ALONE!