IGN over scored it IMO its more of an 8.8, R:FOM was great for its time a dark atmosphere, scary moments, interesting wepons, co-op, 40 player online.. R2 lost the plot it lost the atmosphere and the co-op mode was crap, 60 player online didnt work... as a game it was really good i liked it but as a sequel it changed to much, i hope R3 goes back to the R:FOM formula