Best RPG's of the year and what they did right/wrong.

[ckmlb]

ItsaMii said:

Ari_Gold said:
this thread fails since the best RPG of the year... Persona 3 is not listed

Persona may be better than the ones in the list (IMO the only RPG), but the game sucked. Persona 3 was a average RPG and a weak game from the SMT universe game. It get points for trying some new and original ideas, but that does not save its boring gameplay and dumb storyline.

*edit: the first 2 titles are WRPGs. 

Completely disagree. My favorite RPG in years. I've played pretty much everything people listed, except for The Witcher and Fire Emblem (Starting that soon) and Persona is definitely my favorite of all of them.