Dragon Age or Demon's Soul?!!!! Need some answers!!!!

[lestatdark]

Senlis said:

lestatdark said:

Senlis said:
@GamingChartzFTW

I agree with Zelda owning Demon's Soul. Just making a game hard doesn't make it good, and I disagreed with the direction they took some of the gameplay aspects. I don't know about Baldur's Gate owning Dragon age, since I haven't really played enough Dragon Age, but I suspect it is true.

Out of the two, it really depends on what kind of game you want to play.

I really don't agree with your comment here, because you cannot compare two games from different genres just like this. If you were to compare a Zelda game to Demon's Souls, the only one you can use is Zelda II: Link's Adventure, which also had RPG elements and also had the overall difficulty increased. Although that wouldn't be a fair comparison as well, as Demon's Souls is actually a good RPG, Zelda II was just bad.

Also, didn't you missinterpreted the context of what GamingChartzFTW said? I think he meant that they're similar games to the precursors, but better in his opinion (I beg to differ with the Zelda opinion, but for the reasons I've stated above, you cannot compare different genres just like that.

I read GamingChartz's post wrong.

Ok then, sorry for the long wind-up post then :P