Which would sell more - FFXIII Wii or FFXIII HD

[Xoj]

Soriku said:

Blood_Tears said:
It would sell more on the Wii in Japan but not in the west. If it was on the Wii, the characters would look very kiddy, something like a Wii Madden version.

The game wouldn't sell at all in the west, much like the other 3rd party games on the Wii in the west (FF Crystal Chronicles for example) So to answer the question, HD all the way.

Just like FF X and FF XII and...FFCC: TCB right? Oh wait...

Anyway I'll say HD.

Xoj said:
HD no doubt.

its like 358/2 VS birth by sleep

even with half the userbase psp double DS sales.

 
Because comparing a side story to an arguably main game is totally fair. Well the game won't sell as well as 358 outside of Japan anyway so this point is pretty moot.

Edit:

kingofwale said:

psrock said:
It's final Fantasy folks, it would sell on any console, now that 9 million in Japan would have made a huge difference to me.

would it?? because apparently all but few of those 9 million ignored a Wii game bearing the title "Final Fantasy" just last year.

 
That's because they ignored the game and FF XIII would release in a month's time. Plus the game isn't supposed to be that good either. Comparing TCB to a main FF is laughable to the point of stupidity.

both are side stories, the only difference PSP hardware more in line PS2 games , yet selling like a spinoff, even with so called disney userbase in the DS. its isny a 50k difference, it double DS first week.

and the game if it doesnt sell well outside japan it's mainly because its piracy and lower userbase.

@jarrod, people said the same about FF13, ;)