What was the best game of the decade?

[rocketpig]

guiduc said:

Chrizum said:

rocketpig said:

guiduc said:
Super Mario Galaxy, God of War, Pikmin, Majora's Mask, Twilight Princess, MGS3, Uncharted 2

Those are the revolutionnary games of the decade.

No offense but I look at that list and see a dearth of revolution.

God of War is a button-masher. Those have been around forever. SMG is a Wiimote version of M64. MGS3 is MGS2 with more controls. Uncharted 2 is exactly like Uncharted or any other third person adventurer, just better done than most. MM and TP are straight rips from OoT. Pikmin is, well, Pikmin... Unusual but not exactly revolutionary.

They're all good to great games but I don't see how any of them are really "revolutionary".

I'd say Pikmin really is revolutionary. It's basically an entire new genre, and the best way to bring RTS-style gameplay to the consoles.

Majora's Mask has done new things as well, but to call it a revolution is stretching it.

The rest isn't revolutionary at all.

Hum, thats my opinion here. Do I have the right to consider them revolutionnary, yeah?

You have the right to think anything you want. I just won't agree with you. When put into historical context, I don't see how any of those (outside of Pikmin, which I'll defer on) are anything resembling revolutionary.