Well I can deal with GOTY choice but I would have chosen either Assassin's Creed II or Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks. But either of the three are good choices.
But that's not what I take issue with haha. First and foremost, how best story went to Uncharted 2 is just beyond me. There are loads of better choices, namely Assassin's Creed II. I think they just gave it to it in similar fashion that Oscars give out some stuff. But I don't agree with it nor their choice for it in overall excellence in sound. Second best strategy game being Halo Wars over the likes of Empire: Total War is frustrating. Finally best downloadable game I would not have given to Shadow Complex. Fat Princess or Flower or Splosion Man seemed like better choices to me.
Other than that I think it was a pretty good list. And no I didn't spoil the GOTY.