And you can find far more information than this in the actual thread, from the overall vote tally, to platform awards, to special awards like best new IP, to various averages and percentages, showing which games had the highest average scores and things like that. You can also find links to every GotY thread since 2004 in the OP.
Couple of surprises for me:
1. Infamous got so high. I guess it has its fans, but still. 0_o
2. Mario & Luigi won best DS game. It had some stiff competition, and I thought either Zelda or Layton would take it.
I was also disappointed Left4Dead 2 got beat by Modern Warfare 2.
Other than that, I find the list quite agreeable. The only things I could see myself changing are moving Demon's Souls up to #1 and switching Left4Dead with Call of Duty. I'd probably move New Super Mario Bros. up a few spots as well.