By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
jack100 said:
WilliamWatts said:

Optical drives are not scaling as well to Ram sizes so for every generation it takes longer to read the data needed of disc.


This is the reason that I think Cartridges will come back also.  Everyone wants things to be done faster, if Flash is faster than optical, people will change to flash, assuming that flash is as cheap as optical per GB.  Even if it isn't, what would you rather have, wait for an optical  drive like 10 minutes to load everytime you start up your gaming machine, or pay like $10 extra for a flash version for instanious load. It's like when somene uses a 3.0 GHz PC, and then they try to use a 1.0 GHz PC, most people go crazy cause they don't like that the PC is slow.

Actually its misleading to think of price per GB as game assets aren't exactly scaling much beyond 10-12GB as full motion video isn't required anymore except to hide loading which isn't really needed with flash and not many games will need more than 10GB within the first 2 years of a generation as they are generally just upscaled current generation projects. Comparing say Blu Ray 50GB and expecting the same size flash is just phrasing the problem in a way that will always favour optical drives without any bearing on the reality of the situation.

Also people should remember that flash can be both cheaper and more expensive as a distribution medium. Its cheaper in the sense that if people load up a quick flash cartridge 300MB/S = 8GB in 30s they can simply use kiosks and charge less for this content which cannot be traded or sold, say $50-55 and can also be rented with any stipulations the console maker and publisher agree to such as 7 days or one complete playthrough whichever comes first.

The loading you experience with a console is the time it takes to actually play the game. People say that Uncharted 2 is an example of a load free optical drive game which doesn't require an install. However theres absolutely no backtracking and the time it takes to start is greater than a minute. Furthermore theres no incentive to further punish a player who dies with a time delay as well. I remember an interview from the makers of Forza 3 that when people die/lose its the time they turn off the console. There is no such punishment with a flash cartridge based game.