there is no real point in comparing books and movies as they each do their own thing,
anyway i also agree that the movies are a great watch,i love the exetended versions and will get them on blu-ray for sure,i did see them at the cinema,i do like to catch the big movies at a cinema for full effect,
whats not to like about gandolph and the rest,especially sexy elven women like tyler and blanchett they should have a spin off film,ELVEN FEMALE WARRIORS in sexy cosplay of course,but then in the books the elves get more time than in the films as far as i remember
tolkien did the business if you ask me,the age old battle between light and dark,never fails








