A Western-Developed Final Fantasy - Yay or Nay?

[Xxain]

Jumpin said:
Imagine Western Final Fantasy!
- First Person Shooter
- 95% grey and brown
- a storyline that is as interesting as a dump
- Over 28,000 irrelevant questions to answer to determine whether you are good or evil (good people use magic arrows, bad people use lightning)
- Magic damage is calculated by dice
- It would be totally uber/Epic/1337/hardcore!!!

plz stop... no more, im begging you