No, it's a game that actually delivers. And to the people calling it a mere 'popcorn flick' what game isn't? No game these days reinvents the wheel. They only make incremental improvements on already established ways of playing.
The Uncharted 2 haters who have no other recourse but to argue on a scale of innovation don't realise that EVERY game these days can be criticized using the same standards. Why the fuck does it even matter? It doesn't.