By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

If you're going by 90+ on Metacritic, then the answer is no. As you can see, something has changed. Back in the GameCube days, they'd give 90+ scores to sports games. They gave 90+ scores to 10 sports games on the GameCube. They have given NO 90+ scores to sports games on the Wii. Why that is, I'm not sure, because the Wii is just better at sports games than the GameCube. For example, it's better at golf, baseball, tennis, bowling, and boxing. In fact, they can put all 5 of those sports onto one disc and sell over 50 million copies of it, so I think they're doing something right. But the critics just don't like sports games on Nintendo systems anymore for some reason. Once a sports game sold over 50 million, I guess critics thought they sold out, so they gave up on the whole genre.