BTW - Wouldn't it have been better to ask people to vote like this?
(+) - Most deserving of GoTY title of the remaining games.
(-) - Least deserving of GoTY title of the remaining games.
Then we wouldn't have a situation where Halo 3 is the first to go.
I don't think it is the most deserving game but there are a lot of games on that list that deserve to go well before Halo 3.