Easiest #1 pick for me:
Resistance 2.
Remember the hype for this game? Remember the comparisons it received with Gears of War 2? Remember IGN giving the two games equivalent scores?
What a joke it turned out to be!
It's my fault entirely for buying it, I know, since I didn't like the first game, but... what the hell. I know some people enjoyed it, but, I was disappointed, to say the least.
There are others, though to a much lesser extent. The top scorers this gen (Mario Galaxy, GTAIV) weren't the perfect games they were made out to be. Okami was a disappointment to me as well, I can't get myself to continue the game (about 7 hours in). I also bought MadWorld recently, and... it doesn't look good. I've had to force myself to play it for the first hour and a half, already I'm considering just selling it off.
